Skip to main content

The failure of Dwi Tunggal

 A colleague of mine who is an activist, a cadre, and a high-class staff of the Jogja-based Muslimat NU sent me a modified photo of a pair mate for the president 2024, Anies-Imin, sometime in October saying that the unification of Muhammadiyah-NU, HMI-PMII, would make Indonesia glorified to enter into Indonesia Gold 2045. I replied instantly that it wouldn’t be possible for Muhammadiyah – NU or HMI – PMII to be known to compete with each other in almost all aspects of life in this country, ranging from domestic to nation-state issues and from religious to social ones.

Anies, portrayed as a modernist Muslim, known to be a Muhammadiyah follower and an alumni of HMI, would draw his support from Muhammadiyah and HMI. He gained 41.9% from Muhammadiyah compared to 41.6% by Prabowo, a slight margin of 0.3%. This shows that Anies could not convince them and thus capitalize on his rhetorics of change that Muhammadiyah's followers would vote for him. The slight margin of 0.3% would suggest that Anies failed to draw strong support from Muhammadiyah.

Paired with Muhaimin, known as the chair for the PKB and thus cadres of NU, Anies would also get support from NU. The pair unfortunately could only win 21.8% of the NU traditional followers. This is a huge jab to them for Prabowo-Gibran could draw 55.8%, twice more than Anies-Muhaimin could get.

Those figures show that the attempt to unify Muhammadiyah and NU had failed. The competition between these two Islamic organizations has reached even daily life not excluding the principal of the schools from elementary to high school and higher education. The case is also correct to emphasize the harsh competition between the two in the political arena and even economic matters. If you want to be successful in your career, in politics for example, it is not rare to be asked whether you are affiliated with either Muhammadiyah or NU. 

Popular posts from this blog

Anggaran

Anggaran ... he he he ... hari gini kok bicara anggaran. Others have successfully flown to space several times partly due to well-managed budget, we ridicule ourselves with budgeting for pointless activities. Well, the story commences with BAWASLU and Pokja Waslu Deplu RI who will on 20-21 June 2009 carry out BIMTEK (a short training) on presidential election supervision in Sydney for Sydney, Melbourne, Kuala Lumpur, Penang, Kinabalu, Kuching and Johor Baru-based WASLU LN. Other BIMTEK will also be conducted in four cities, i.e. SEOUL (for Tokyo, Seoul, Hongkong, Taipei, Singapore, Brunei and Davao City-based WASLU LN), NEW YORK (for New York and Los Angeles-based WASLU LN), LONDON (for Den Haag, London and Frankfurt-based WASLU LN) and CAIRO (for Cairo, Jeddah, Riyadh, Kuwait and Dubai-based WASLU LN). This BIMTEK is to train members of WASLU LN (overseas-based team for supervising election) to monitor and supervise presidential election due on 8 July 2009. The question to be raised h...
Read more

Bravo BAWASLU

Iya Bravo BAWASLU dan Congrat ya pada Pokja Waslu yang telah merelokasi peserta BIMTEK Waslu LN dari Sydney ke Kuala Lumpur dan regrouping peserta dari Singapura, Brunei dan Davao City yang awalnya dikelompokkan di Seoul dipindah ke Kuala Lumpur. Ini semua dilakukan dengan mulya dengan menjunjung tinggi kepentingan bangsa dan negara mengappresiasi kepentingan hakat rakyat banyak yaitu perlunya effisiensi anggaran. I thought all Indonesia bureaucrats were close-minded. Well, my assumption has just turned to be wrong for few or even some are open-minded, are bright and intelligent for bright and better Indonesia. My appreciation goes to you BAWASLU and Pokja Waslu LN. See you all in Kuala Lumpur on 20 June 2009.
Read more